Mortgage Broker vs. Bank: Who Should I Choose?

If you are shopping around for mortgage rates, It’s good to know what to expect (or not expect) from dealing with mortgage brokers or going directly to the big banks.

Before buying our first home, I really didn’t understand the differences between mortgage brokers and banks. I just assumed they were all one and the same.

However, after we decided it was time to start hunting for our first home, I started doing my research on mortgage brokers, mortgage rates, mortgage pre-approvals, and much more.

Canadians are in love with their big banks! Mortgage Professionals Canada’s 2016 Spring Survey showed that only 36% of future home buyers intended to consult a mortgage broker, while 66% of respondents would consult a bank.

For the sake of clarity, I define mortgage brokers as intermediaries or middlemen between lenders and prospective home buyers (i.e. borrowers). They shop around for the best rates, negotiate on your behalf, sort out the paperwork, and get paid a commission for their services from the lending institution after the deal is completed.

Most jurisdictions in Canada require mortgage brokers to be licensed and accredited members of Mortgage Professionals Canada are required to complete Continuing Education Units each year to maintain their designation.

Banks have loan officers who interface with clients to provide mortgage services directly. Loan officers work with clients to choose a mortgage product offered in-house by the bank.

Mortgage Broker vs. Bank (Pros and Cons)

When you are looking at obtaining a mortgage loan, should you go directly to a big bank or use a mortgage broker to find the best deals possible?

What factors should you be considering – Mortgage rates? Mortgage terms and conditions? Services offered?

Pros of using a Mortgage Broker

1. Free Personalized Service: A mortgage broker will not charge you a fee for shopping around for the most competitive rates. They are paid a finder’s fee by lenders. You can expect them to assist you with completing your application, providing advice on what documentation is needed, what the next steps are, etc.

With the growing popularity of online mortgage brokers, you can do all of your communication by email and phone calls. Mortgage brokers have an incentive to keep you happy and will try to make the process as pain-free as possible for you.

2. Save Time and Effort: Who has the time to research, negotiate with or contact 30 different lenders while shopping for competitive rates?

Well, mortgage brokers! They have access to a large pool of lenders including major banks, private lenders, and other financial institutions. Unlike the loan officer at the big bank, they are not “married” to any one lender.

3. Experience: Mortgage brokers have vast knowledge, tools, and lending options at their disposal which they use to secure low rate mortgages. For those with a poor credit history or low income, a mortgage broker may be the only recourse to getting a mortgage loan.

4. Click of a Mouse: With the advent of online rate comparison sites like IntelliMortgage and Ratehub, you can compare several rates from different lenders before choosing one to work with.

Cons of Using a Mortgage Broker

1. Commission Disincentive: Since lenders pay brokers commission fees after closing a deal, there is a potential conflict of interest. For example, if a lender pays more based on volume or other terms, a broker may tend to recommend them more often, and not exhaust the entire universe of lending options available.

This is only an issue if the lender recommended doesn’t have the best rate for your circumstances. To avoid this problem, use more than one mortgage broker and compare their offers.

2. Terms and Conditions: Apart from rates, mortgages also come with terms and conditions such as prepayment terms, porting rules, payment deferral options, penalty clauses, etc. While the mortgage broker is expected to highlight these differences and explain them to you, you can’t bank on them.

The lowest rate may come with unfavourable conditions that make them more expensive in the long run. For instance, prepayment or lump-sum payments may be severely limited. This means you cannot afford to just stay on the sidelines and take whatever is offered to you. You should ask questions.

3. Access to non-broker Lenders: Some of the big banks run their own show with in-house staff (mortgage specialists or advisors). If they are not paying mortgage brokers a commission or “finders’ fee”, they have no incentive to check with these lenders or to recommend them. This essentially reduces the pool of lenders being consulted for the best rates.

Pros of working directly with a Big Bank

1. Familiarity: If you have an existing good relationship with a bank, you get the benefit of being familiar with bank staff and their processes, and may be offered special perks and competitive rates for being a loyal customer. As a longstanding client, you may have some negotiating power.

2. Other Perks: Obtaining your mortgage direct from a bank opens other opportunities and perks that may not be available when negotiating through a mortgage broker. These include access to a home equity line of credit (HELOC) and the bank may pay for a home appraisal, etc.

3. Trustworthiness Factor: Some people feel more comfortable with the “brick and mortar” feel of a bank. Major banks are perceived to be “safe” and more accountable for their actions.

4. One-Stop Financial Shop: This is the convenience factor. It can be more convenient to have all your financial dealings – savings, chequing, investments, and mortgage with the same financial institution. For this reason alone, some will rather just go directly to their bank to obtain a mortgage.

Related: Intellimortgage Review – Get the Best Rates.

Cons of the Big Bank

1. Usually Higher Rates: Rates posted by the major banks are usually higher than the lowest rate available. If you are unable to negotiate a discount, you may be paying a lot more in interest fees (think several thousands of dollars extra) over the life of your mortgage.

2. Fewer Options: A bank loan officer will only consider their in-house products when offering you a rate. You lose out on the ability to compare rates across different lenders.

3. Negotiation: The bank loan officer is not obliged to offer you the best discount on their posted rate. You have to work for it. They get paid commissions on their sales and the onus is on you to negotiate the best deal that you can get.

4. Stricter Conditions for Approval: The major banks have stricter rules in place (for good reason) for approving mortgages. A mortgage shopper with a poor credit history or low income may have better success working with a mortgage broker.

A Word About Credit Unions

Most mortgage shoppers forget about credit unions when shopping around for a competitive mortgage rate. However, credit unions often beat the banks when it comes to posted rates and should not be overlooked.

Some credit unions also offer their members extra benefits including profit-sharing.


Shop around! When we were mortgage shopping, we started with the big banks, moved on to online mortgage brokers, and ended up with a credit union.

When you get a good rate, do your homework and check the fine prints and penalty clauses. If you decide to go with a mortgage broker, make sure you check online rate comparison sites for a general idea of the latest competitive rates.

Related Posts:

What was your experience working with a mortgage broker or your bank? Let us know in the comments.

Mortgage Brokers vs. Big Banks: Who Should I Choose infographic
Retirement 101 eBook - 3D


Photo of author
Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu is a personal finance expert and a veterinarian. He has a master’s degree in Finance and Investment Management from the University of Aberdeen Business School (Scotland) and has completed several courses and certificates in finance, including the Canadian Securities Course. He also has an MSc. in Agricultural Economics from the University of Manitoba and a Doctor of Veterinary Medicine degree from the University of Ibadan. Enoch has a passion for helping others win with their personal finances and has been writing about money matters for over a decade. He has been featured or quoted in The Globe and Mail, Winnipeg Free Press, Wealthsimple, Financial Post, Toronto Star, CTV News, Canadian Securities Exchange, Credit Canada, National Post, CIBC, and many other personal finance publications.

His top investment tools include Wealthsimple and Questrade. He earns cash back on purchases using KOHO, monitors his credit score for free using Borrowell, and earns interest on savings through EQ Bank.

1 thought on “Mortgage Broker vs. Bank: Who Should I Choose?”

  1. Excellent information, truly helpful. thank you for sharing

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.