Are Extended Warranties Worth it in Canada?

Photo of author

by Enoch Omololu


Advertiser Disclosure

Have you recently purchased a new sofa to furnish your new house? Are you in the market to buy new big-ticket items? Electronics? Appliances? Car? Computer? Smartphone?

When you buy a new item these days, you’re inundated with requests by the salesperson to buy an extended warranty.

In-store sales staff frequently paint a picture of accidental damage to your purchase that may leave you high and dry.

They often promote the store’s extended warranty as covering pretty much everything (often untrue!) and many a customer have shelled out hundreds of dollars for extended warranties that are pretty much worthless!

Are these extended warranties worth it?

It depends.

The consensus among consumer protection agencies and advocates is that extended warranties are often not worth it.

According to Consumer Reports, buying a service plan (aka extended warranty) is usually “money down the drain.”

Reasons why an Extended Warranty may not be required

1. Manufacturer’s Warranty: Products and appliances often come with a manufacturer’s warranty that covers you from several days to years. Make sure you’re not doubling up and paying for what’s already covered.

2. Consumer Protection Legislation: Consumers in Canada have certain rights and protections under the law. Products are generally expected to be fit for their intended purpose and have a reasonable life expectancy and durability.

The extent of protection varies by Province, so check with your provincial consumer protection office for the applicable warranty provisions.

3. Credit Card Protection: Many credit cards offer warranties that extend the manufacturer’s warranty when you purchase the product using the card. This coverage is free and may offer to repair, replace, or refund.

The free Tangerine World Mastercard offers a free extended warranty that doubles the manufacturer’s regular warranty for up to an additional year.

4. Product Reliability: Appliances rarely break during the extended warranty period (1-3 years). Granted, there’s no guarantee that this will be your experience.

5. Warranty vs. Repair Costs: An extended warranty does not necessarily mean you’re fully covered. Read the fine print and check what’s covered. There may be exceptions embedded in the terms and conditions of the warranty that render it absolutely useless for your needs.

Also, consider if it’s cheaper for you to just bear the cost of potential repairs if/when they occur.

5 Reasons To Decline Extended Warranties. Extended warranties are generally a waste of your money. Learn about the reasons why and what to do instead of purchasing an extended warranty when next you are purchasing your next big-ticket item. #savemoney #moneytips #savingmoney #frugal #personalfinance #moneyaffirmations

Alternatives to Buying an Extended Warranty

I have long stopped purchasing extended warranties because I agree that it’s often a waste of money. This was after I had succumbed a few times to sales pressure tactics and bought extended coverage for a tablet, TV, and an office chair (dumb, yes I know!).

By the way, none of these items I purchased an extended warranty for broke down during the coverage period.

Savvy alternatives to purchasing an extended warranty include:

1. Save for the rainy day: Instead of paying for extended warranties, consider putting the funds instead into a high-interest savings account or emergency fund. If any of your purchases break down, you now have a repair or replace fund you can tap into.

2. Do your research: I do extensive research before buying pretty much anything over $20 (sometimes even less). Check reviews of the product online to see what other users have to say about its reliability. Compare and contrast between similar products, manufacturer’s warranties, return policies, etc.

3. Become a DIY Enthusiast: Embrace the Do-It-Yourself (DIY) life. There are loads of resources online detailing how to do minor and major repairs on nearly everything you can think of.

Youtube is my go-to for excellent how-to videos when I’m looking for repair tips. Of course, this approach comes with its own risks. Proceed with caution! 😉

Extended Warranty FAQs

Should I buy an extended warranty on a new car?

The car manufacturer’s warranty generally covers costs of major repairs during the first few years of a new car and you don’t need to pay out of pocket. If you feel the need to, you can purchase coverage after the manufacturer’s warranty expires for peace of mind.

Should I buy an extended warranty on a used car?

Generally, no. You could save money by planning ahead and keeping an emergency fund for repairs. That said, if the car you are buying has a history of being unreliable, an extended warranty that is fairly priced may be worth it.

Also Read:

Have extended warranties proven to be useful to you? Tell us about your experience in the comments.

Best Money Saving Offers this month

Get one of the highest savings interest rates in Canada at *3.00%*

Earn a high 3.00% interest rate on your deposits.

No monthly fees or minimum balance is required.

Promo interest is available until October 31, 2022.

Easily open a free chequing account and get a $350 bonus.

Best no-fee cash back credit card with a $100 welcome bonus

Earn 2% unlimited cashback in three categories of spending.

Get a $100 sign-up bonus on $1,000 spending in the first 2 months.

0.50% cashback on all other purchases and no annual fee.

Only requires a $12,000 income and 600+ credit score.

This free card offers cashback on debit purchases ($20 bonus)

Best prepaid card in Canada.

Earn 0.50% cash back on all purchases and up to 10% at select partners.

Save automatically and earn 1.20% interest on your cash balance.

$20 bonus after making your first purchase (use CASHBACK referral code during signup).

Get the "Canadian Cashback App" for free and $5 bonus

Earn real cash back when you shop at popular retailers.

No need to upload receipts; get paid by Interac e-Transfer.

Top cashback app owned by RBC and $5 sign-up bonus (AMPLI5).

Over $2 million has been paid in cashback and prizes.

Get paid to shop online using Rakuten with $30 cash bonus

Earn cashback on purchases at 750+ stores.

Up to 30% cashback discounts are available daily.

Redeem cash rewards by PayPal or cheque.

Get a $30 bonus after your first purchase of $30 or more.

Retirement 101 eBook - 3D


Photo of author
Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu is a personal finance expert and a veterinarian. He has a master’s degree in Finance and Investment Management from the University of Aberdeen Business School (Scotland) and has completed several courses and certificates in finance, including the Canadian Securities Course. He also has an MSc. in Agricultural Economics from the University of Manitoba and a Doctor of Veterinary Medicine degree from the University of Ibadan. Enoch has a passion for helping others win with their personal finances and has been writing about money matters for over a decade. He has been featured or quoted in The Globe and Mail, Winnipeg Free Press, Wealthsimple, Financial Post, Toronto Star, CTV News, Canadian Securities Exchange, Credit Canada, National Post, CIBC, and many other personal finance publications.

His top investment tools include Wealthsimple and Questrade. He earns cash back on purchases using KOHO, monitors his credit score for free using Borrowell, and earns interest on savings through EQ Bank.

2 thoughts on “Are Extended Warranties Worth it in Canada?”

  1. I agree that with the extended warranties that come with many credit cards nowadays, there’s no need to even consider buying one from the store (which are a waste of money anyways, like you say). I think perhaps the only exception would be items that have many moving parts and are notorious for breaking down, like treadmills.

    • Hi Miguel. Yes, I agree that some items are probably best protected with insurance especially when you consider the pain you have to go through to remove, discard, or repair. Your treadmill example is spot-on. Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.